These fact sheets are for information only. It is recommended that you get legal advice about your situation. These resources have been produced with funding from NSW Office of Fair Trading.
Problems with the quality of repairs arranged by the insurer
If you have had repairs done by your insurer and you are unsatisfied with the quality of workmanship or parts used or the timeliness of the work there are steps you can take. Regardless who actually does the work be the insurer’s authorised repairer or a subcontractor the insurance company is reasonable for the quality of the repairs.
Justin’s car was damaged in a car accident. Justin claimed on his car insurance for the damage with BIG INSURANCE COM-PANY. The insurer approved the claim and his car was fixed at JOE’S SMASH REPAIRER. Justin was unhappy with the quality of the work done on his vehicle. Justin requested BIG INSUR-ANCE COMPANY repair the vehicle to a satisfactory standard.
BIG INSURANCE COMPANY said that they have paid for the repairs and that Justin will have to sort out his issues with the smash repairer directly. Justin wrote to the insurance company’s internal dispute resolution section describing what works was unsatisfactory and he also pointed out that the insurer is responsible for the quality of authorised repairs and they must perform the required work. 15 days later the insurance company sent him a letter stating they did not believe the repairs were necessary.
Justin lodged a complaint with the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). Following a period of mediation, AFCA found that insurer had to fix the repair work and Justin vehicle was returned to him in same condition it was prior the crash.
WHAT CAN I DO IF I AM UNSATISFIED WITH QUALITY OF THE REPAIRS AN INSURANCE COMPANY HAS COMPLETED ON YOUR VEHICLE OR HOUSE?
If you have had repairs done by your insurer and you are unsatisfied with the quality of workmanship or parts used or the timeliness of the work there are steps you can take. Regardless who actually does the work be it the insurer’s authorised repairer or a subcontractor the insurance company is responsible for the quality of the repairs.
The General Insurance Code of Practice states that when an insurer has selected and directly authorised a repairer they “will:
- Accept responsibility for the quality of workmanship and materials;
- Handle any complaint about the quality or timeliness of the work or conduct of the repairer as part of our complaints handling process.” (Clause 7.20 General Insurance Code of Practice)
In general, if repair work to your house or vehicle is not to your satisfaction you may do the following:
- Request that the insurer fixes the problem.
- If you’re insurer refuses to fix the problem lodge a complaint with your insurer’s Internal Dispute Resolution Scheme. You can get the contact details for their IDR from Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) ‘find a financial firm’ web page. Make sure you clearly outline the reasons for your complaint.
- Your insurer has 45 days to provide you with written response outlining their decision.
- If your insurer refuses to fix the repairs or does not respond in 45 days, you can lodge a complaint with AFCA. To lodge a claim call AFCA on 1800 931 678 or visit the website www.afca.org.au to get the relevant forms.
- After investigating the matter:
- If AFCA finds in your favour the insurer is obligated to carry out the repairs; or,
- If AFCA finds in favour of the insurer you still have the option of taking the insurer to court – but remember ALWAYS GET LEGAL ADVICE BEFORE GOING TO COURT!
IMPORTANT: YOUR TIME LIMIT TO LODGE A COMPLAINT IN AFCA WILL EXPIRE ON THE EARLIEST OF;
- 2 years from the date you receive a letter rejecting your claim from the insurer’s Internal Dispute Resolution Department; or
- 6 years from when you first became aware or should have reasonably become aware of your loss (e.g within 6 years from the date of the motor vehicle accident, theft or flood)
NOTE: If you have received a letter of rejection from the insurer’s IDR department, the two year time limit will apply.
WHAT IF I HAVE MY CAR REPAIRED BY THE OTHER DRIVER’S INSURANCE COMPANY?
Sometimes the other driver’s insurance company will offer to repair you car for you. Always get legal advice prior to accepting such an offer because if you are unhappy with the repairs you do not have access to AFCA and your only option will be to take the other driver’s insurance company to court – and this can be expensive and risky!
NEED SOME MORE HELP?
See Fact sheet: Getting help for a list of additional resources.
Last updated: October 2018